News

Classical Considerations: Beyond the Orchestra

No avid listener of classical music will be shocked, when reviewing the instrumentation of a classical piece, to see the occasional inclusion of artillery. Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture, originally penned as a celebration of Russia’s defeat of Napoleon, has become a mainstay of American Independence Day commemorations and ends in a cataclysm of brass, chimes, and gunpowder. What may come as a surprise is that the original scoring does not call for a cannon at all but for a “Bombardone” (a type of drum) about which Tchaikovsky, in writing to his publisher, clarifies:

“Regarding the Bombardone, kindly learn from the theater the name of the instrument they use for a cannon, i.e. the large suspended drum which is beaten like a gran cassa. If it has no name, and I’m actually mistaken in calling this thing a bombardon, then instead of Bombardone in the score, put Canon, or Colpi di Canone, or Canons, or Coups de canons, or in Russian cannon… not a real cannon, but a drum.”1

This is not to say that, had Tchaikovsky intended it, the inclusion of an actual cannon would’ve been completely unheard of. Cannon fire has been used in operatic scoring since at least the 1700s and Beethoven’s Battle Symphony (1812) calls for a veritable battalion of artillery effects including the use of a musket.2

In addition to the firearms to which you would’ve had to endure as a symphony-goer of the 19th century there were a variety of other frightfully inventive inclusions to the orchestra: Leopold Mozart’s Jagdsinfonie includes the intermittent yelping of hounds, Wagner’s Das Rheingold calls for “18 anvils of varying sizes (tuned to 3 octaves of F#)” to be struck with a hammer, and Mahler’s Sixth Symphony calls for something affectionately known as the “mahler hammer” which is supposed to sound something like “the fall of an ax.”

Audiences through the ages have responded to these alternative instrumental choices in a variety of ways. Giuseppe Sarti’s Russian Oratorio, which calls for cannon fire, was greeted with critical acclaim for its celebration of the Russian capture of Ochakov in 1788.3 In contrast Mahler, for the inclusion of his hammer, was broadly ridiculed by critics of the day.4

Mahler was roundly jeered for the inclusion of “non-instruments”

Audiences have always had mixed reactions to these unconventional instruments, but there’s more to consider than just the sound they make. When we hear a harp along with the sound of the strings vibrating, we hear the echoes of all the images that come with it. Harp music doesn’t just produce sound; it also brings to mind angels, heaven’s gates, and a touch of the divine. Similarly, an organ carries with it the cavern of a church, a pan flute summons the image of a shepherd on a hillside, and a cowbell calls for, well, cows.

With that in mind, what truly counts as an instrument? If L. Mozart wants us to feel like we’re on a hunt, and he’s already using the horns and drums to set the scene, doesn’t it make sense to toss in the hounds and musket fire, too? If the composer intends to transport us, than the more tools they have at their disposal the better, right? And if Beethoven is trying to immerse us in the Battle of Vitoria with a massive 100-piece orchestra, perhaps we should be upset if he decides to skip the cannon and give us a quieter, less exciting version of the fight?

On the flip side, it’s hard not to feel for the concertgoer who just wants a clean evening of beautiful music. After all, isn’t the magic of a composer’s craft in how they create vivid scenes and emotions using nothing but conventional instruments? If you have to leave a concert with gunpowder in your hair, maybe that’s taking things a bit too far.

– Matthew Young

Many of the composers referenced above including Leopold Mozart, Richard Wagner, and Pyotr Tchaikovsky are featured this fall on TheClassicalStation.org, so please take a look at our Fall 2024 Highlights to see when to tune in, or request a piece directly via one of our Request Programs! 


1. https://en.tchaikovsky-research.net/pages/The_Year_1812#cite_note-note21-2↩
2. https://unheardbeethoven.org/search.php?Identifier=hess97↩
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giuseppe_Sarti↩
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._6_(Mahler)↩

Next Stops on The Classical Station

Keep listening, keep learning. Here are three pieces to take you one click deeper.

Explore the full archive anytime at TheClassicalStation.org.

Now Playing

Symphony No. 5, Op. 107 "Reformation"

Composed by

Felix Mendelssohn (1809-1847)

Performed by

Israel Philharmonic/Bernstein

Label

DG

Catalog Number

289

Today's Playlist

3:33pm By the River from Florida Suite

Composed by

Frederick Delius (1862-1934)

Performed by

Bournemouth Symphony/Hickox

3:41pm Theme & Variations in C sharp minor, Op. 73

Composed by

Gabriel Faure (1845-1924)

Performed by

Jean Martin

4:00pm Concerto Serenata for Harp and Orchestra

Composed by

Joaquin Rodrigo (1901-1999)

Performed by

Zabaleta/Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra/Marzendorfer

4:25pm La plus que lente

Composed by

Claude Debussy (1862-1918)

Performed by

Alexis Weissenberg

4:30pm La Bayadere: Suite

Composed by

Leon Minkus (1826-1917)

Performed by

Sofia National Opera Orchestra/Spassov

5:00pm Divertimento No. 11 in D, K. 251 "Nannerl Septet"

Composed by

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791)

Performed by

Berlin PhilharmonicAbbado

5:27pm Three Romances for Violin and Piano, Op. 22

Composed by

Clara Schumann (1819-1896)

Performed by

Jodry/Boschi

5:39pm Quintet in D, Op. 2 No. 6

Composed by

Johann Christian Bach (1735-1782)

Performed by

Pohlers/Sous/Kehr/Schmid/Buhl

5:51pm Music selected by the announcer

6:01pm Baisies moy dont fort, ma maistreusse, 'Kiss me ardently, then, my mistress'

Composed by

Johannes Ockeghem (c.1410-1497)

Performed by

Blue Heron/Metcalfe

6:08pm Missa super Veni in hortum meum

Composed by

Orlando de Lassus (c1532-1594)

Performed by

Brabant Ensemble/Rice

6:27pm Concerto for Two Horns in F, RV 538

Composed by

Antonio Vivaldi (1678-1741)

Performed by

Cafe Zimmermann/Valetti

6:38pm Orchestral Suite in D, FaWV K: D16

Composed by

Johann Friedrich Fasch (1688-1759)

Performed by

Tempesta di Mare - Philadelphia Baroque Orchestra/Roberts/Stone

7:01pm Castor and Pollux: Overture

Composed by

Georg Joseph Vogler (1749-1814)

Performed by

Munich Radio Orchestra/Griffiths

7:12pm Symphony No. 2 in D

Composed by

Friedrich Witt (1770-1836)

Performed by

Cologne Academy/Willens

7:36pm Piano Trio in E flat, Op. 101 No. 1

Composed by

Anton Reicha (1770–1836)

Performed by

Trio Bohemo

8:01pm Roses from the South, Op. 388

Composed by

Johann Strauss Jr. (1825-1899)

Performed by

Vienna Philharmonic/Nezet-Seguin

8:11pm Symphony No. 1, Op. 13

Composed by

George Enescu (1881-1955)

Performed by

Orchestre National de France/Macelaru

8:44pm Variations on "Loth to Depart"

Composed by

Imogen Holst (1907-1984)

Performed by

BBC Concert Orchestra/Farnham

9:01pm Requiem

Composed by

John Rutter (1945-)

Performed by

Ashton/Deam/Cambridge Singers/Rutter

9:39pm Variations on a Folksong "Peter, Go Ring Dem Bells"

Composed by

Florence Price (1887-1953)

Performed by

Tom Winpenny

9:52pm The Enchanted Lake, Op. 62

Composed by

Anatol Liadov (1855-1914)

Performed by

BBC Symphony/Titov

10:02pm Ubi caritas et amor from Four Motets on Gregorian Themes, Op. 10

Composed by

Maurice Durufle (1902-1986)

Performed by

Choir of St. John's, Elora/Edison

10:06pm Sospiri, Op. 70

Composed by

Edward Elgar (1857-1934)

Performed by

Vienna Philharmonic/Gardiner

10:12pm Concerto Antico for Guitar and Small Orchestra

Composed by

Richard Harvey (b.1953)

Performed by

Williams/London Symphony/Daniel

10:42pm Abendlied from Three Sacred Songs, Op. 69

Composed by

Joseph Gabriel Rheinberger (1839-1901)

Performed by

St. Clement's Choir, Philadelphia/Conte

10:46pm Gnossienne No. 3

Composed by

Eric Satie (1866-1925)

Performed by

Simone Dinnerstein

10:52pm Divenire for violin, cello, strings and two harps

Composed by

Ludovico Einaudi, arr. by Paul Bateman

Performed by

Samuelsen/Samuelsen/RLPO/Petrenko

11:00pm Nunc dimittis

Composed by

Gustav Holst (1874-1934)

Performed by

Winchester Cathedral Choir/Hill

11:06pm From Thuringia

Composed by

Joseph Joachim Raff (1822-1882)

Performed by

Czechoslovak State Philharmonic/Edlinger

11:42pm Music selected by the announcer