Deutsche Grammophon’s recent release of Sergei Prokofiev’s Scythian Suite and Lieutenant Kijé, performed by The Chicago Symphony Orchestra under conductor Claudio Abbado, is innovative in its engineering and “old school” in its delivery.

For Deutsche Grammophon’s “Original Source” series of vinyl they’ve gone back to basics, using the original one-inch, eight-track tapes with the original analogue source to mix and cut this new vinyl release. And when I say vinyl, I mean vinyl: The recording is delivered on 180 grams of solid vinyl like I haven’t held in decades. This is a serious record. It’s virtually unbendable, with a heft that feels like a record that has to sound good.

And the recording delivers on that impression! The audio separation is not only distinct, you can hear a clarity of inner voices that aren’t nearly as apparent on the original vinyl release. There are orchestral effects at several points of Lieutenant Kijé, most notably the violins in the Noces de Kijé section, that I’ve never heard so distinctly. They made such an impression that I went back to my score and wondered, “Wow! How did I miss that?” Compared to the CD release, you’ll hear a less homogenized sound without the seemingly manipulated orchestral balances.

On side A of the album is Sergei Prokofiev’s Scythian Suite. Here again, the clarity of inner voices allows for a perspective on the work that I’d never heard. The piece engaged me differently and I enjoyed it, probably for the first time. Interestingly enough, the only other recording of Scythian Suite I’ve ever owned was the original vinyl version of this same album, which sounded muddled to me and more difficult to hear. This new vinyl release brings the performance to life. Fans of the Scythian Suite will find a great interpretation here. If you haven’t enjoyed the piece before, this recording may be the one to change your mind.

On side B of the album, Claudio Abbado’s interpretation of Lieutenant Kijé offers a subtle deviousness as the army clerks plot to deceive their king. The dark humor of the plot weaves its way through the movements as the king blindly believes his clerks, and through his reactions, further advances their deception.

The brass section, crucial to the performance of both these works, is pure gold. Led by Bud Herseth, The Chicago Symphony’s principal trumpet for 53 years, the opening trumpet call of Lieutenant Kijé is ethereal. The brass is recorded with a clarity and brilliance that reminds me of hearing them live at Carnegie Hall 50 years ago. In 1977, The Chicago Symphony Orchestra was at the top of its game. Claudio Abbado expertly manages the resources at his disposal to deliver performances to rival any other.

This was my first opportunity to hear the “Original Source” series from Deutsche Grammophon. If the rest of the series is produced as well as this release, this product is as good as new vinyl gets.

— Vince Tillona

Enjoy what you’ve read? Tune-in every Monday evening at 7pm EST to Drop the Needle where your host Vince Tillona shares insights, anecdotes and all the most exciting classical vinyl, only on TheClassicalStation.org!